The spirit of Vatican II: the idealist aspects of liturgical architecture in Europe
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to provide a comprehensive overview of the “idealist” intellectual workshops behind the 20th-century liturgical architecture before and after the Second Vatican Council. These workshops established their concepts on the intriguingly historic presumption that, in order to refresh the Catholic liturgy, one must seek and return to the origins of Christianity. In other words, their worldview was characterized by the spirit of ressourcement, which was one of the great motivators of the new liturgical paradigm brought about by 1962. Ressourcement had both monastic and secular aspects to the invocation – or recreation – of the early apostolic communities by means of new spatial and contextual programs in contemporary church architecture. These programs were conceptually compound, and were often guided or implemented by the clergy itself. The study also sheds light on some of the 21th-century interpretations and the survival of the same ideas in today’s architectural culture.
Keyword : contemporary liturgical architecture, modern churches, liturgical reform, Second Vatican Council, Benedictine Order, Early Christian architecture, ressourcement
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
References
Böhringer, H. (2006). Szinte Semmi: Életművészet és más művészetek [Almost nothing: Art of living and other arts]. Balassi.
Bouyer, L. (1991). Architecture et liturgie (impr. 1967). Cerf.
Brinkmann, U. (2005). Am Platz der Menschenrechte: Kirchenzentrum in der Messestadt München-Riem. Bauwelt, 96(35), 14–21.
Crippa, M. A. (2009). Romano Guardini & Marie-Alain Couturier: The sources of architecture and art for the 20th century Catholic liturgy. In E. Fernández-Cobián (Ed.), Arquitecturas de lo sagrado: Memoria y proyecto (pp. 178–205). Netbiblo.
Debuyst, F. (2005). A hely szelleme a keresztény építészetben (trans. from “Le génie chrétien du lieu” by Klára Szilágyi). Bencés.
Ferlenga, A., & Verde, P. (2000). Dom Hans van der Laan: Le opere, gli scritti. Electa.
Fernández-Cobián, E. (2009). Contemporary religious architecture: The state of the art. In E. Fernández-Cobián (Ed.), Arquitecturas de lo sagrado: Memoria y proyecto (pp. 8–37). Netbiblo.
Fischer, J. O. (2006). Inner sanctum. Architecture, 95(3), 48–53.
Földváry, M. I. (2003). A kultikus tér szerveződése a kereszténységben [The organization of cultic space in Christianity]. In B. Barsi & M. I. Földváry, „Belépek Isten Oltárához” – Bevezetés a templom misztériumába (pp. 105–169). Vágó Lajos Gábor.
Földváry, M. I. (2006). A latin rítusú templomtér kialakításának mai lehetőségei [Contemporary possibilities of designing Latin Rite church interiors] In J. Pánczél Hegedűs J. (Ed.), A jó harc: Tanulmányok az ősi római rítusról és a katolikus szent hagyományról (pp. 151–177). La Magione / Miles Christi.
Frampton, K. (1996). Rappel à l’ordre, the Case for the Tectonic [1990]. In K. Nesbitt (Ed.), Theorizing a new agenda for architecture: An anthology of architectural theory 1965–1995 (pp. 518–528). Princeton Architectural Press.
GIRM / General Instruction on the Roman Missal (3rd typical ed.). (2003). Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments.
Gregory, R. (2009). San Giacomo Church, Foligno, Umbria, Italy. Architectural Review, 225(1347), 40–49.
Guardini, R. (1998). The spirit of the liturgy (A. Lane, Trans.). Crossroad.
Heidegger, M. (1971). The origin of the work of art (A. Hofstadter, Trans.). In Poetry, language, thought (pp. 143–162). Harper & Row.
Hinkfoth, U. (2009). Harte Hülle, expressiver Kern: Zeitgenössischer Kirchenbau in Deutschland. Archithese, 39(2), 26–33.
Kocik, T. M. (2012). The ‘reform of the reform’ in broad context: Re-engaging the living tradition. Usus Antiquior, 3(2), 102–114. https://doi.org/10.1179/1757894912Z.0000000007
Laan, D. H. (1992). Der architektonische Raum: Fünfzehn Lektionen über die Disposition der menschlichen Behausung. Brill.
Lang, U. M. (2004). Turning towards the Lord: Orientation in liturgical prayer. Ignatius.
López-Arias, F. (2021). El Concilio Vaticano II y la arquitectura sagrada: Origen y evolución de unos principios programáticos (1947–1970). CLV Edizioni.
Mangado, P. (2007). Ignacio Vicens y José Antonio Ramos. Arquitectura, (350), 4–23.
Meck Architekten. (2008). Pfarrzentrum Sankt Nikolaus, Neuried [Website]. https://www.meck-architekten.de/projekte/id/2008-pfarrzentrum-sankt-nikolaus
Nagy, G. (2007). “Gyere velem egy külön helyre pihenni” – Ferences ifjúsági tanya kápolnája, Erzsébettelep [The chapel of the Franciscan youth farm in Erzsébettelep, Hungary]. Régi-Új Magyar Építőművészet / Hungarian Architecture, (4), 31.
ODEA / Ordo dedicationis ecclesiae et altaris (1st typical ed.). (1977). Typis Polyglottis Vaticanis.
Oubrerie, J. (2009). The Church of Saint-Pierre in Firminy, by José Oubrerie and Le Corbusier. In E. Fernández-Cobián (Ed.), Arquitecturas de lo sagrado: Memoria y proyecto (pp. 162–177). Netbiblo.
Padovan, R. (2002). Dom Hans Van Der Laan and the plastic number. In K. Williams & J. F. Rodrigues (Eds.), Nexus IV: Architecture and mathematics. Kim Williams Books.
Ratzinger, J. (2000). The spirit of the liturgy (J. Saward, Trans.). Ignatius.
Regula / St. Benedict’s Rule for Monasteries (L. J. Doyle, Trans.). (1948). The Liturgical Press.
Riepl, P., & Riepl, G. (2004). Neue Spielräume öffnen! – Creating new spatial dimensions. Detail, 44(9), 995–997.
Schnell, H. (1974). Twentieth century church architecture in Germany (P. J. Dine, Trans.). Schnell & Steiner.
Stock, W. J. (2004). Architectural guide: Christian sacred buildings in Europe since 1950. Prestel.
Vicens Hualde, I. (2009). Twenty five years of religious architecture. In E. Fernández-Cobián (Ed.), Arquitecturas de lo sagrado: Memoria y proyecto (pp. 72–91). Netbiblo.
Wessely, H. (2005). Kirchenzentrum in München-Riem. Detail, 45(10), 1124–1130.
Wöhler, T. (2005). Neue Architektur Sakralbauten. Braun.
Zahner, W. (2009). Church-building in Germany during the 20th and 21st centuries: In search of a house for God and men. In E. Fernández-Cobián (Ed.), Arquitecturas de lo sagrado: Memoria y proyecto (pp. 38–71). Netbiblo.